The best full book on the subject of Unbelieving Husbands (there’s not many) but it’s hard for me to recommend.
Summary
Jo Berry’s book, “Beloved Unbeliever,” is one of the few books on it’s topic. Berry starts with what it means to be unequally yoked, how they got there, how to be a biblical wife, and then moves to techniques to better live with an unsaved husband and the challenges that come. A good amount of what Berry says is thought provoking or Biblical advice, but unfortunately the areas where she is weak are very large and I think would be detrimental to the reader who is severely struggling with this issue.
At first attempt I wasn’t sure and only got a few pages in. On my second attempt I really enjoyed the book and thought it was helpful with some concerns. As I wrote this review and thought about it longer, the concerns are very concerning and I would not recommend this book for discipleship or discussion. I recommend the chapter in Women Helping Women about Unsaved Husbands even though it is much shorter.
Score Breakdown:
Treatment of Scripture:
Berry references scripture throughout the book. My preference would be for more in-text citations throughout, but her best points are grounded in a text. Berry seems to have a literal, grammatical, historical hermeneutic. She is not expositional in her but does a good job defining key terms. She generally seems accurate in her interpretations and definitions, though there are a few places where she makes exegetical leaps that I am not 100% on. She struggles with clarity on continuity (the role of the OT in the NT believer) as she creates a one to one of marriage to foreigners in Ezra early on, and then clarifies much later on how it was under the OT law and different for us. She stays mostly in the NT for the book, and does well with that. I think she does think of scripture highly and her “Workshop” section is generally completely based in looking up verses.
Despite all these things, a good portion of the book is made up of knowledge based on experience. The advice and thoughts generally seem pretty good, but it is not evaluated or backed up by scripture. A lot of the more practical things she says is just stated (sometimes very firmly) without scriptural basis and I want to be cautious of. Other things are based on quotations of experiences of other women. These are interesting, but taken as a prescription of what to do instead of opinion or God’s work in their situation. These quotes are rarely interacted with by some sort of biblical support or analysis.
She sometimes makes assumptions of the reader’s position (which I do think are generally correct ex: the reader is someone who wants to go to church), but doesn’t preface her instruction so if you do not read the chapter (or book) quickly this may cause problems. She also doesn’t address the biblical idea of appealing to your husband, though she does a good job discussing passivity vs. submission.
CAVEAT #1:
Berry does struggle with understanding ecclesiology and doctrine and incorrectly pendulum swings in her discussions of it. She separates obeying God and going to church. She instructs that going to church is optional at some level. She doesn’t discuss service in the church, church a passive consuming event. She believes that midweek Bible studies are equal to Sunday church attendance. She says that a husbands spiritual needs are above the spiritual needs of the wife (even though he is unsaved and the wisdom of God will be foolish). She doesn’t address Luke 14:26. Instead she advices almost the opposite, “she must never maker her husband feel like she is choosing the Lord over him…she must remember that it is Christ, not the church, that demands her allegiance. (p. 85)” Later on, Berry briefly mentions putting God first (p. 140), but the tone of the book is the husband first. In contrast to this, in Women Helping Women by Fitzpatrick and Cornish says almost the complete opposite and say that church attendance is a non-negotiable, she needs to serve, and needs to be poured into. That it is inevitable that the husband will see that the wife is choosing the Lord over him, because God is her king now, not the husband. She also does not seem to understand the role of membership and the commitment one makes to a church, how leaving shouldn’t be seen lightly. Berry also never in the book mentions going to a pastor or elder in the church for counsel and help in spiritual matters.
CAVEAT #2:
Berry believes that doctrinal conviction and theology are dogmatic and prideful. She promotes going to a church with weak or false theology if that’s when the husband will go. Berry also doesn’t address how to deal with not being able to do something in faith (Romans 14:23). “An unequally yoked wife must keep in mind that what matters spiritually is that her husband place his faith in Christ and acknowledge him as savior, not that he go to her church or do it her way or interpret every doctrine as she does. She must be open-minded, rejecting prejudice and stereotypes, eliminating the preconceived ideas that are based on habit and conjecture rather than fact. (p. 153)” Berry does not seem to believe in God’s providence in what the husband hears at church when they attend together because she suggests going wherever the (spiritually dead) husband wants. It doesn’t seem to be an option (in this chapter) that the husband would be offended because he is hardening his heart against God. Though earlier she does assert that the husbands are spiritually dead and will not understand. She does backtrack and say that “she doesn’t have to compromise her beliefs… (p. 153)” But she believes that “dogmatism can be deadly if carried beyond basic convictions. (p. 152)”
This is the clearest place in the book, but throughout the book Berry hints and warns about being overly “pious” and having strong convictions. It seems that she doesn’t believe that some denominations and “churches” do not teach the gospel and are not saved people because in her belief there is not bad place to go, all churches will be accurate about the gospel. I do think that there can be differences in convictions about things and this is something every couple has to work through. I also see perhaps to be willing to go to another good church after consulting her elders. But I do genuinely believe that there are many churches that do not present the gospel and moving her/her family to another church on the off chance her husband will get saved is not something I would recommend for who knows if doing that will save her husband (1 Cor 7:16).
CAVEAT #3:
In the chapter about “Drawing the Line” and dealing with abuse, Berry says that an unbelieving spouse leaving as per 1 Cor 7:15 can be a leaving of the heart, “if he neglects her needs and destroys her as a person…mentally he has left…in his sick mind, the relationship is over. (p. 120)” I haven’t studied this passage, but I feel like we should be cautious about this idea because too often this could be a justification for divorce. Perhaps because the author does not believe divorce is permissible (on the side of an unbeliever), then this solves this issue. I DO believe that someone who is being abused should leave that situation immediately (see https://abuse.biblicalcounseling.com/ for my position).
CAVEAT #4:
In the chapter about “Shouldering Spiritual Responsibility” Berry discusses prayer (which is good). Then she recommended a prayer method for unsaved people, which is a bit weird and mystical leaning, “concentrate on Jesus’ life. Visualize it penetrating the darkness of sin…hand that person over to Jesus and envision Him wrapping him in His arms, completely submerging him in His light and His love…then mentally commit the person to that position from then on.(p. 109)”
Biblical Goals:
Berry’s goal on the front cover is “how to love your husband into the faith.” This was a big turn off for me. But within the book Berry does discuss how women cannot force or change their husbands, that it is a work of the Lord. Berry also says on the back cover that “happiness is possible in an unequally yoked situation.” I think throughout this book we see this tension. Berry says a lot of good and helpful things that are right and biblical. A lot of what she says is right! But she does not discuss godliness as happiness, or being near to God as happiness, or glorifying God as happiness. Much of her advice is centered on obeying God as a wife or an wife to an unbeliever and then shifts into minimizing pressure points and perhaps even building up the self-esteem of the husband. I don’t think that trying to minimize areas of conflict is necessarily bad, but having that as the goal is incorrect. I DO think that women in such marriages can have joy in such marriages. But having happiness of the goal will diminish some of God’s commands. As you read it is not obvious that her goal is happiness instead of God’s glory, but if you think about it you will see this as a tint throughout most of what she says. This is very different than Women Helping Women’s chapter on this which clearly discusses the importance of being like Jesus and God’s glory and how this will produce joy and fulfillment.
Biblical Terminology:
Berry does a fair job of using biblical terminology throughout the book. She discusses sin, judgement, mercy, salvation, hell, obedience, and forgiveness. She even has a brief “Workshop” section that goes into the heart (p. 131) though she doesn’t discuss the heart very much, which is expected of 1980. She does use some psychologized terms like “needs,” “cope,” and “self-esteem.” She does label things as obedience, but less things are labeled as sin (anxiety is not clearly labeled a sin). She doesn’t clearly define many of these terms and even the terms she uses from passages. Some definitions of things made me pause and I am unsure on (like the definition of faithful on pg. 28). It’s completely wrong, just I’m not sure.
Biblical Hope:
Berry is not clear on what the reader’s hope is in. On the one hand, hope is in God working in the husband’s heart. Hope in in the Lord giving joy and relief. On the other hand, as you read it also seems like hope is in a lot of techniques you can do to make your husband happy and to change your perspective. Of course changing perspective to being more biblical is great and would help. She does not clearly go through promises of God that would be comforting. She does zoom through a handful of God’s attributes (with no scripture references) on page 141.
Gospel Concepts:
Berry does present an accurate gospel. She discusses sin, need for a savior, and eternal destinies. She is much less clear on the holiness of God and repentance. I think this is reflective of the church “zeitgiest” of the time in the 1980s. To make matters worse, later on in the book it seems like she is confused on how one actually is regenerated and presents differing views as equal, “Some think you receive Him silently, by making a commitment in your heart; others by being baptized in water; and some may say conversion only happens when you speak in tongues. (p. 152)” Unfortunately though, if you are saved by baptism then it is a work. And if I’m being semantically precise even if we think that praying in our hearts or speaking in tongues is what saves us, then that is a work also! Faith and repentance is necessary for salvation, but it is not what saves us.
Practicality and Helpfulness:
This book is practical and seeks to be very helpful. Application is easily gleaned and much of the content is based on interviews with women implementing things they learned in their life. But her application can be very superficial. This isn’t bad, but her application doesn’t necessarily address the heart. In some of the situations she presents, her answers don’t seem adequate to handle the situation.
Discipleship Use:
For discipleship use, on paper this is a great book to use. It’s formatted for discipleship with helpful “Workshop” homework style questions, discussion questions, and even a chapter on how to start a unequally yoked ministry. The book is really easy to read and well written. Each chapter would give plenty of content for discussion.
CAVEAT #6:
For some reason, there are few books on this topic though this issue is very common. This is the best one I saw and it was recommended by Faith Lafayette, but I would not recommend. Overall the chapter in Women Helping Women on Unsaved Husbands is very short, but very helpful and very solid. I would recommend that instead even though it is much shorter. With some creativity and meditation on how to apply, that chapter will be enough to help women with this issue.
Personal Use:
Personally this book was helpful and interesting. There were a few sections I really enjoyed and think will help me in my own marriage. But the longer I thought about this book, the more concerning it was. I probably will not reread this book, though it is interesting.
Caveat #5: Author Background
I struggled (in my limited research) to find a robust description of Jo Berry’s beliefs and what church she was apart of when she was writing books. She was featured on Dr. Dobson’s radio show, but I am not sure if that reflects her theological positions. While a decent amount of what she says is solid, the positions on ecclesiology are concerning.
